State your point/topic (First sentence) – Simons narration is significant in Disaster – Chapter 5
Expand with relevant background detail – Simons narration is told through Joe’s perspective, however, Simon validated Joe’s account as “fair and correct” Simons “Voice” reveals that he resented Joes injury and that he felt justified in distancing himself from Joe.
Examples (Specific) – The text states… The reader is told… It is revealed… Words like… The selected text… tells us…
Response (Your response)
– What does the reader learn
– What does the reader think, visualize, feel
– What connections can the reader make to other experiences of contexts
– What is the overall purpose, message
The reader understands from this narration that Simon is calculating the value of his life against Joes. He also treats the situation logically and considers the odds of their survival, if Joe is assisted down the mountain. This presents the interesting reality about human nature: should we risk our own life for others? When does our commitment to a person end? Is it excusable to relinquish responsibility when we are endangered ourselves?
Joe and Simon face many struggles when they are trying to get back down the mountain. The most obvious of these being Joes broken leg which prevents him from climbing down himself meaning Simon has to help him. Another problem is the extreme cold, Both Simon and Joe are both suffering from minor frostbite and this is very bad for Simon as he has to uses his hands to lower Joe down.
The phrase on the edge can be used in many ways with many different meanings. It can mean being on the edge of a cliff or rock face or it can mean being close to making a final decision. On edge can also mean someone is very tense, and also being close to something happening, generally bad or disastrous. I think that it can refer to any of these as it is used in the title.
Foreshadowing is a language feature that is used by Joe to hint that something bad might happen. An example is that Joe often talks about how high up on the cliff they are and also how dangerous it would be to fall and would most certainly end in his and Simon’s death. This makes the reader feel that Joe and Simon might experience a fall similar to one Joe describes that Simon has experienced. Simon was climbing and he watched two Japanese climbers fall to their death, I feel that this hints towards the fact that Simon and Joe might also fall down and suffer the same fate
I think that this has been included in the text because it shows that Joe and Simon are very ambitious people and are willing to do whatever it takes to achieve their goal. This also reveals that Joe and Simon are very dedicated to climbing that they are almost being controlled by the mountain that they are trying to climb. It also shows Joe doubting why he was attempting to scale Siula Grande, was he doing it for pleasure or was he doing it for glory and egotism. It shows that the dangerous men mentioned are doubting why they are doing what they are doing.
Question 1. The specialized jargon used is not explained in the text because the author thinks that the reader would get the rough idea of what the words mean so they get the idea without having to explain it. The reader is expected to bring their own experiences to the text. He can also assume that the reader has some knowledge of climbing if they are reading the book.
1 Karrimats are sleeping pads or mats and are important in the text because it is what Jo and Simon are sleeping on.
2 Rock Piton is a nail type object designed to be hammered into the rock so to create a point to clip your self to the rock which is what Simon and Jo will be using it for.
3 A ravine formed by water may be a feature on a mountain that Jo and Simon could be climbing up.
4 Seracs are a pinnacle or ridge on the surface of a glacier which could be an obstacle that they would have to overcome.
5 Ice screws are screws that can be drilled into an ice wall so they are connected to a wall so Jo and Simon can put their weight on them allowing them to belay.
6 A cascade is a waterfall that keeps a steady flow of water over the width of the waterfall. And this relates to the story because they are trying to find them because it would be better ice to climb.
In chapter 2 of Joe Simpson’s book ” Touching The Void ” Joe and Simon are climbing, They have a special relationship that is shown time and time again. When Joe is aching Simon volunteers to go first because he knows Joe is at a disadvantage. Since Joe and Simon have been climbing together for so long they know each other’s strengths and weaknesses so they know when the other person might need a little bit more support.
The environment they are climbing in is a difficult climb, and at the beginning of the chapter they are enjoying it because of the challenge but then when the ice began to break away under there ice picks they realized the danger and began to worry about the other person getting hit, which is another sign of their great friendship.
When Joe has a ” Flashback ” he remembers the time that he was climbing with Ian Whittaker and they were climbing really well, but when they found a suitable place to sleep when Joe fell and was saved only by his safety rope, The ledge they were resting on had fallen taking all their equipment with it so Joe and Ian were left hanging above the face in just their socks unable to climb out. The rope holding them was very fragile and they had to place their lives in its care for 12 long hours until their screams for help were heard and a rescue helicopter came to their rescue. Ian returned to the Alps but he had lost his interest in climbing, whereas Joe now was mostly over it and now only had a fear of bivouacs.